…And Who’s Benefiting?
Integrated supply and demand, Market economies, corporate accountability - I feel like I’m back in Marketing 101. These are all excellent topics of discussion over a glass of pinot, but what do they have to do with being a designer?
Well, firstly, I think the book has it wrong. The book implies that corporate giants have The Power. I think this is a flawed view of corporate responsibility. In fact, it is the consumers that hold the real power.
Is it really good enough that only 1% of starbuck’s coffee is fair trade? What would happen to the world economy and the lives of farmers in impoverished countries if starbuck’s made a commitment to have 10%, 50% or 100% fair trade product?
The fact that walmart has the lowest prices, and they keep falling, is a great selling point and a necessity for many low-middle income families. Many people would not be able to afford or purchase products such as necessary sanitary products or fishing gear or nascar hats if it weren’t for the walmart down the block. But is the saving of a few dollars really worth the cost of poor production standards, inhumane working conditions, and unethical business practices? The problem is not that walmart does not want to improve these things, the problem is that as consumers, we dont care.
With the advances in technology and a focus on being able to produce gecko shoes, are we really using this technology to better our world? The science is there, there are numbers and statistics to prove it: Humans are Smart. But who is influencing whom, and who is benefitting?
Why do we not use our “smartness” to question corporate practices and bring on true Massive Change. Why are we content with 1% when we can have 100%? Why are we satisfied with the extremely poor quality in the products we buy, only to replace them and have them fill our landfills?
So in conclusion, the book states that corporate giants have the power to bring on massive change. Maybe, in fact this statement is true, but only if we as consumers are willing to forfeit our own power.